How to Make Pastrami Yourself at Home and Two Other Great Sandwiches

Pastrami is one of the most iconic deli-style meats in the world. The reddish, smoked, lightly sweet and tangy brisket piled high on rye, with or without kraut, maybe 1000 Island dressing and a slice of Swiss cheese has made even the most discriminating of sandwich eaters crumple into their chairs after the first bite. It is simply that good and memorable for many, especially those who grew up in NYC or as we will discover later, neighborhoods in LA.

Let me first say that I don’t pretend to know everything about NY-style delis nor even the food of the various ethnic neighborhoods of the outer boroughs. But I DO know what good pastrami tastes like.

You can imagine how I felt when I discovered that with a little time and a little knowledge, I good bring this quintessential deli meat home, and can now add to my list of perfect Sunday afternoon sandwiches, right next to the BLT.


This slightly sweet, tangy and peppery deli-style meat comes to us via New York from Jewish immigrants that (probably) came from Lithuania or somewhere near there and was first served in a uniquely Jewish-American store, called the delicatessen. Hundreds of “delis” sprang up around New York and the surrounding boroughs as Jews came by the millions to the big cities of the US in the late 1800s and early 1900s.

Jewish-American food is unique, meaning, it doesn’t come from the Old Testament or from Orthodox traditions, rather, it comes from the Jews who moved into Central and Eastern Europe, blended their “kosher” lifestyle with local food, accessible ingredients, etc. Food like lox, bagels, corned beef, knish, latkes, matzo ball soup and so forth is deeply rooted in this tradition. As Jews melted into the societies in Central and Eastern Europe, their religious eating traditions became something that we would now recognize. For example, there is no mention of latkes in the Torah and certainly not pastrami but since beef brisket (the base of pastrami and corned beef) was a cheaper cut and available, it became a mainstay in the Seder meal throughout Europe and eventually the US.

So that beautiful but tough cut of the cow, the brisket, that is now celebrated not only during Passover but around BBQs all over, developed into what we would recognize as corned beef and pastrami, most likely as a way to preserve the meat to make it last longer (since there is some slight pickling done – certainly in corned beef).

Pastrami has the same basic heritage. Note: this was a super-skimmed version of Jewish-Euro-US history that is missing a few points…but you get it.

These delis became world-famous and while there were thousands over 50 years ago, there are only a fraction left, and even fewer still who do a great job. So…why not try and do it at home? Who doesn’t like a stacked and steamed pastrami sandwich on rye? Me and so should you! One of the very best sandwiches EVER, especially if you include their close cousins, the Reuben.

Home Cured Pastrami

  • 1 gallon water
  • 1 1/2 cup kosher salt
  • 1 cup white sugar
  • 1 1/2 oz pink salt
  • 1 T pickling spice
  • 1/2 cup brown sugar
  • 1/4 cup honey
  • 5 garlic cloves

Combine all above in a stock pot, bring to a boil, let cool completely.

1, 5 pound brisket with big and heavy fat removed.

Place brisket into 2 gallon ziplock bag and dump cooled brine, seal and set for 3 days, rotating each day. After 3 days, discard brine, rinse brisket, pat dry (I like to place on a cooling rack over a cookie sheet) and then sprinkle equal amounts of coriander seeds and black peppercorns ( 1 T, smashed with mortar and pestle or something) over the entire brisket.

Smoke on your grill (150-200 degrees) or in oven at same temp for 2-3 hours or until internal temperature is 150 degrees.

Once smoked, place in 1 inch of water in a pan that a lid can fit over top (or if you don’t have you can eventually cover with foil) bring to a simmer and then place into oven at 275 degrees for another 2-3 hours. Ready to slice and serve!

At this point you can wrap tightly and store (I take to my local butcher and have them cut it “deli thin” for me).


“Katz Deli” Style

Steamed pastrami (stacked high!)
Rye bread (caraway, marbled, brown, whatever you like or can find)
Spicy brown mustard
Dill pickle

“West Coast Style”

(not sure why I am calling it this way, except that I guess I read somewhere that in LA someone is making it this way and it is awesome)

Steamed pastrami
Rye – same as above
2-4 T Russian dressing
1/4 cup cole slaw
Swiss cheese

For Both –

Enough pastrami to make however many sandwiches you want placed wrapped in aluminum foil and placed in a steam basket over simmering water for 15-20 minutes or until all pastrami is cooked through.

Either toast your bread slightly (my preference) or wrap your sandwich slices in tin foil and place in oven at 300 degrees for about 15 minutes.

Assemble however you like!

Photo credit to Katz / FB

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *